top of page
Outdoor dining table set for two surrounded by lush tropical plants
Best Italian Restaurant Key West

Italian flavors meet Island Charm

WHAT'S ON THE TABLE

Savor the vibrant flavors of coastal Italy with fresh, local ingredients from the Keys. Handmade pastas, wood-fired pizzas, fresh seafood, and signature meat dishes are paired perfectly with handcrafted cocktails and curated wines.

DINNER MENU

Served Daily from 5PM - 9:30PM Summer has arrived at Conchiglia.


Appetizers



CAPRESE DI CAPRI

Fresh mozzarella, sweet tomatoes, basil, toasted ciabatta, aged balsamic


SAN DANIELE ON THE VERANDA

Creamy burrata, 24 month-cured prosciutto, Dalmatia fig preserve, wild arugula


PORTOBELLO AL FORNO

Wood-roasted portobello mushroom, bell peppers, melted mozzarella


ISLAND FRITTO MISTO

Polenta-crusted shrimp, calamari and zucchini with lime aioli


CARPACCIO DELLA CASA

Silky beef carpaccio, black truffle aioli, pickled mushrooms, Parmigiano, toasted hazelnuts*




Salads



AMALFI ARUGULA

Arugula, shaved pecorino, toasted walnuts, citrus vinaigrette. Add herbed lemon chicken +9


DUVAL’S GARDEN

Mixed greens with tomato, carrot, Italian olives, house white balsamic dressing


AEGEAN AFTERNOON

Heirloom tomatoes, cucumber, barrel-aged feta, kalamata olives, oregano vinaigrette




Pasta



RAVIOLI RICOTTA & SPINACI

Ricotta and spinach ravioli in slow-braised house pomodoro with shaved Parmigiano


SPAGHETTI ALLE VONGOLE

Italian durum wheat pasta with fresh clams in a delicate white wine sauce


CONCHIGLIA BAKED GNOCCHI (GF)

Potato gnocchi in house pomodoro, topped with melted mozzarella, baked in our stone oven until golden. Gluten free.


LINGUINE NERE

Squid-ink linguine in seafood broth with shrimp, mussels, calamari, octopus, clams and local snapper


TAGLIATELLE AL RAGÙ BOLOGNESE

Fresh tagliatelle with slow Barolo-braised Prime Beef ragù and rich San Marzano sauce


ROMAN HOLIDAY “CACIO E PEPE”

Bucatini with pecorino and black pepper, pure Roman!


THE TRUFFLE RITUAL

Wild mushroom and truffled pecorino risotto with black truffle carpaccio, served in Pecorino wheel




Main Course



CHICKEN PICCATA

Tender organic chicken breast with lemon, white wine and capers, served with sautéed broccolini


PESCATO ALL’ACQUA PAZZA

Local snapper with tomato confit, clams, aqua pazza broth


SALMONE ALLA GRIGLIA

Grilled salmon fillet with salsa verde and saffron beurre blanc, sautéed broccolini


AUSTRALIAN LAMB CHOP

Grilled Australian lamb chop with rosemary-roasted potatoes and grilled asparagus


CHICKEN PARMIGIANA

Breaded chicken breast with San Marzano sauce and fresh mozzarella


TAGLIATA DI PRIME RIBEYE

Grilled Prime ribeye steak with arugula, Parmigiano, aged balsamic, rosemary potatoes*




Pizza



MARGHERITA ON DUVAL

San Marzano tomato, fresh mozzarella, basil


ITALIAN SAUSAGE & CAPRINO

Fennel sausage, roasted mushrooms, goat cheese, truffle oil


CAPRICCIOSA CLASSICA

Artichokes, ham, olives, mushrooms — the full Italian story


PEPPERONI STORM

Mozzarella, spicy pepperoni, San Marzano tomato


PROSCIUTTO CONCHIGLIA

Mozzarella, tomato, Italian prosciutto and shaved Parmigiano


PINK SHRIMP SCAMPI

Garlic-EVOO base, Key West pink shrimp, parsley, key-lime salmoriglio sauce




Sides



BROCCOLINI AL LIMONE

Tender broccolini with bright lemon, Calabrian chili, and toasted almonds


PATATE AL ROSMARINO

Crisp potatoes roasted with rosemary and garlic


GRILLED ASPARAGUS

Char-grilled asparagus, lightly marinated and simply seasoned


HOUSE TRUFFLED POLENTA

Slow-cooked stone-ground polenta with aged Parmigiano and black truffle


bottom of page